November 18, 2026

Where We’re Winning: Generosity at Upward Christian Fellowship – Episode 475

podcast image size (6)

Fresh Content Each Week

New content to help you lead an unstuck church delivered to your inbox on Wednesday mornings.

We know your inbox is probably full.

We want to make it easier for you to find the right content-the articles, podcast episodes and resources most relevant to where you are in your leadership.

  • Protected: Order – August 7, 2021 @ 01:25 AM

    Podcast Episodes

  • Articles & Blog Posts

  • Protected: Order – August 7, 2021 @ 09:59 AM

    Quarterly Unstuck Church Report

More than almost anything else, our finances compete for our hearts. And when money wins (which it often does), trust in God as a provider erodes.

Generosity is a vital part of the discipleship process. If we shortchange it, we leave people undiscipled in one of the most critical areas of faith and life. So, how do you talk about giving as a spiritual discipline without it being weird?

To find out, Sean sat down with Andy Craver, lead pastor of Upward Christian Fellowship in Flat Rock, NC, and author of Keep the Change: Transforming Your Community Through Radical Generosity. In 2020, instead of taking the PPP loan, Upward gave away $27,000, building a culture of radical generosity in their church.  

In this episode, Sean and Jimmy talk about how Upward Christian makes generous disciples.

  • The power of stories
  • Generosity as a step of faith
  • How much fun generosity can be

When we focus on discipleship in the church, the people in our church benefit from that, and the church also benefits with more resources for ministry. [episode 475] #unstuckchurch Share on X Anybody can be generous when you have a surplus on your hands, money to burn, but it takes courage to chose to be generous in uncertain times. [episode 475] #unstuckchurch Share on X Be a generous church before you ask people to be generous people. [episode 475] #unstuckchurch Share on X
planning center full color@3x

This Episode Is Brought to You By Planning Center.

Planning Center is software designed to help churches help people. With multiple tools in one connected platform, you can stay organized, communicate with your team, and create meaningful ways to connect with your congregation.

Start for free at planningcenter.com—pay only for what you need, and cancel anytime.


Get the Leader Conversation Guide

Opt-in here and get access to the Leader Conversation Guide for this episode and to the full archive. Emailed each Wednesday.


Share Your Thoughts and Questions on Social Media

We use hashtag #unstuckchurch on X @unstuckgroup and on Instagram @theunstuckgroup. 


Write a Review—It Helps!

Your ratings and reviews really do help more pastors discover the podcast content we’re creating here. Would you take a minute to share your thoughts? Just open the podcast on iTunes on your phone or computer, click Ratings & Reviews, and leave your opinion. Or leave us 5 stars on Spotify.


Transcript 

Sean: 

Welcome to the Unstuck Church Podcast. I’m Sean Bublitz, your host. This is episode three of our series on where churches are winning, specifically in how they’re helping people grow as disciples of Jesus. I’m joined again by Jimmy McLoud. Jimmy’s the lead pastor at First Christian Church in Canton, Ohio, and an unstuck consultant here at the Unstuck Group. Jimmy, what stood out to you so far in this series? We’re two episodes in. Any highlights for you?

Jimmy: 

First of all, I’m loving this series. It’s been so nice to celebrate and learn from some churches who are getting it right with discipleship. This is an area, and what we’re gonna talk about today, where there will always be room for innovation; there will always be room for improvement. I hope leaders who are listening to this series are encouraged and inspired to hear stories of real churches that are proving that the results that we wanna see in our churches are possible. 

What’s probably stood out to me more than anything is the common thread that I picked up on in the first two episodes: neither one of those churches began to win in their different areas of the discipleship pathway because they added a program. Usually that’s what we think we need to do to turn a corner: add something new, add a program or something along those lines. For these churches, the momentum started when they said, “Let’s change the way we think,” and they figured that out. And for some of them, like ONE&ALL we talked last week, it took them a year to figure out what that shift was gonna look like. But then they built great systems around those different ways of thinking. They built great systems to back it up. And I’m excited that we get to shine a spotlight on another great church today that’s doing the same thing in this area of discipleship.

Sean: 

Absolutely. You mentioned last week we were talking about serving, and we shared my conversation with Jesus Ariaga from ONE&ALL Church down in San Dimas, California. Beautiful area. Jesus told me about how they grew 21% in a year and they still, at the same time, had 88% of their church engaged in serving. They intentionally changed their language from, “We need you,” to “You need this.” They simplified their signup process, built up a follow-up system, they celebrated volunteers like crazy, and they put a discipleship pastor at every campus to own it. So an amazing shift in strategy that created great results for them. 

This week, we’re shifting to another part of the discipleship pathway, and that’s generosity. Jimmy, I think this is a really important week of the series. Every single church leader knows the reality of funding ministry. We’re nonprofit organizations. We’re funded by the generosity of the people who call our church home. At the same time, as we talked about back in episode one, generosity is one of those catalysts for spiritual growth. And there’s data behind that, and we’ll get into that in just a minute. 

So before we dive into this week’s conversation, let me say thanks to our podcast sponsor, Planning Center. If you’re a church that’s struggling just to stay organized and keep people connected, Planning Center is an all-in-one church management software built to simplify administration so that you can spend your time focusing on people. With Planning Center, you can track first-time guests, schedule volunteers, manage check-ins, accept online giving, all in one place. So if you’re interested in learning more, you can go over to planningcenter.com. 

Jimmy, I don’t think we need to spend a long time on the tension with generosity and giving. If you’re a church leader, the cost of doing ministry is not trending down. You know that. Ministry costs are a lot like feeding a teenager. Jimmy, I’ve got three teenagers at my house right now, two soon-to-be teenagers. The costs of feeding them only go one direction and always faster than I feel like I’ve actually set aside budget for.

Jimmy: 

Now you’re preaching.

Sean: 

If you’re building anything right now, you’ve seen what construction costs have done over the last five years. If you have a staff team, you know what it costs to take care of them, right? Some of you might be in shock today looking at health insurance costs for next year. And the general budget fund items aren’t getting cheaper either. But here’s the thing: ministry needs more resources, but we don’t have a product to sell. We have people to disciple. And we don’t disciple them so that we can twist their arm into giving more. We disciple them so that they can decide how God wants them to give. 

Scripture’s already given us guidance on this. Give what you’ve decided to give in your heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion, because God loves a cheerful giver. That’s 2 Corinthians 9. Give according to what you have, not according to what you don’t have. 2 Corinthians 8. Set aside a sum regularly in keeping with your income. 1 Corinthians 16. And honor the Lord with your wealth, your first fruits. Proverbs 3. So decided, proportional, regular, first, in that order of scriptures that I just read. That’s not a fundraising strategy, that’s discipleship. 

Jimmy, one challenge I’ve seen is that some pastors, maybe most, if I could say that, don’t really like talking about generosity and giving. Have you seen the same thing? Or maybe you feel that?

Jimmy: 

Yeah. It’s weird. We don’t like talking about stuff that we think people don’t want us to talk about, right? I think most pastors would rather preach on hell than money because hell feels less personal somehow. I get the tension, Sean. It can feel self-serving to get up in front of your church and ask them to give when they know they’re paying your paycheck. And money’s a deeply personal thing. There’s that fear in your mind that you’re gonna offend somebody and they’ll leave the church or maybe a first-time guest picked that Sunday to try church for the first time. And it’s like, man, we talk about money once a quarter, and you showed up on this Sunday. You think about those things, and I felt all of those tensions and more. 

So many pastors don’t talk about money and when they do, to make it worse, they do it apologetically. And the problem with that is Jesus talked about money constantly, more than almost any other subject in Scripture, and he never apologized for it. He knew that more than almost anything else, our finances compete for our hearts, and usually money wins, unfortunately. And when money wins, our trust in God as a provider erodes. So pastors, listen, if we shortchange this vital part of the discipleship process, we’re leaving people undiscipled in one of the areas that is most critical to faith in life. And ultimately, that leads to weaker churches that make little to no gospel impact in their community.

Sean: 

Jimmy, you just reminded me. It was back in episode 392. I did an interview with Pastor Jason Anderson, and it was a great conversation on how to not hate preaching on money. So if pastors are interested in listening to that, you can go back to 392. I think this is the key thing that pastors need to remember as they’re processing this and thinking about how they prepare to talk about it. People who are spiritually engaged, they’re practicing the spiritual disciplines, they’re leading in the church, they are far more likely to also give to the church. 

Earlier this year on the podcast, we shared some research from Horizon Stewardship that said people who are engaged in groups or serving give three and a half times more of their income than people who attend just once or twice a month. Which means that the last two weeks, as we talked about serving and groups, they weren’t only about groups and serving, they were actually about generosity too. When we focus on discipleship in the church, the people in our church benefit from that, and the church also benefits with more resources for ministry. Have you seen that play out at First Christian?

Jimmy: 

Yeah, we’ve pretty radically changed the way that we approach the subject of generosity in the past few years, just trying to learn from churches that are doing well in that area. Right now, we are winding down the first year of a generosity initiative; back in the day we’d have called that a capital campaign. So I’ve really had to stretch and grow a lot more in this area of my leadership in the past year. And every time I preach on generosity, what I’ve tried to do is be intentional about three key things. I try to include these. T

he first one, and you’ve already hinted at this, is generosity is about more than your money. I want people to hear me say it’s about your time and your talent as well as your treasure, and it’s how you steward all those finite resources that God’s given you. So we need to teach people to be good stewards of those things and view them in their proper context as resources that are owned by God, and we get to manage them, but our job is to manage them his way. So that’s number one. 

The second thing is I remind our people that generosity is not a money issue. It’s a discipleship issue. I will tell them it’s not a money thing; it’s a heart thing. And Jesus does not want your wallet. Money is not his concern, but he does want your heart, and he knows that his greatest competition for your heart is your money. T

he third thing is, I try to just give clear, direct Bible teaching. There’s an illustration I use, and I can’t remember the first place I heard this, so I can’t take credit for thinking of this, but it’s a great illustration. I’ll tell our church, let’s imagine you and I sit down for coffee and you say, “Man, Jimmy, I needed to tell you something. I’ve been having an affair. I’ve been cheating on my spouse, and I just needed to get that off my chest.” I’ll tell our church, “Here’s what I would not do as your pastor. I would not say, ‘Wow, I’m really sorry to hear that, but listen, I want you to take some steps here. What I’d love for you to do is just slow down like 3%, just cheat on your spouse 3% less and just go from there,’ right?” Of course, I wouldn’t say that. I’d be like, stop it, cut off communication, end it, break the relationship. It’s over, confess, repent, all those kinds of things.

Well, what I communicate with that illustration is, where I think a lot of pastors have done harm to their churches is sometimes by giving this teaching in a soft way. We try to give people these on-ramps where it’s like, maybe you can only give 1%, so just give 1%. Well, when I look at Scripture, the teaching seems to be a little more clear than that. So I think we wanna have grace for people there, but I didn’t write the Word. And so what I owe our church is clarity, and I owe them direct teaching, understanding it’s not my idea; these aren’t my concepts. And I’ve stopped apologizing for teaching on the subject of generosity with our church. And I’ve started telling them, I want you to experience the full blessing of God in the financial aspects of your life. And I believe God’s made promises to you that he’ll honor if you’re obedient in this area. So I’m gonna teach you what he said. If you don’t like it, tell him. I’m the mailman, but you take it up with him. 

And I’ve just tried to be really clear and direct. I’ll challenge people to identify what they value in their life and I’ll tell them, if you’re having trouble figuring it out, look at your calendar and your bank statement because then you’ll know. ‘Cause where your treasure is, your heart’s gonna be found. So we tweaked other stuff, more practical things like the timing of when we talk about generosity and how we present it and all that kind of stuff. Lots of intentional strategic shifts. 

But the biggest thing is when we talk about money, we try to tell stories and tie generosity back to what it’s actually doing, that it’s not just keeping the lights on, but it’s changing lives. If we can help people connect their giving to how lives are being changed, then everything else is just so much easier to talk about because they get the mission of it. 

As a result, our church, 12 or 13 years ago, we were in a pretty major financial crisis and we weren’t even sure we were gonna make it. And now it looks like 2026 is gonna be the best financial year in our church’s history. And I don’t take credit for that. We’ve been so thankful to learn from incredible churches like the one that you’re about to talk about who are doing so well. And that’s why I love this podcast series. It’s made a difference. This kind of stuff has changed our church’s life. And I think some people listening to what you’re about to talk about, Sean, they’re gonna feel that before long too.

Sean: 

Yeah, absolutely. So I wanna tell our listeners about a church that I had the honor to start working with way back in 2019, which feels like a different lifetime ago because that was before COVID. And they’ve really been on a journey with this whole generosity thing. Andy Craver is the lead pastor of Upward Christian Fellowship in Flat Rock, North Carolina. He also wrote a whole book about their journey in generosity. It’s called Keep the Change: Transforming Your Community Through Radical Generosity. I’d really encourage church leaders, pick up this book, go get it on Amazon. And I even love what Andy and the team are doing with the proceeds of this book to reinvest it. 

Upward’s whole story has a lot of great chapters to it. This generosity thing might be the best one. So back when the pandemic started in 2020, they had the same concerns that every church had. Andy told me they decided at the time they weren’t gonna take the PPP loan. They don’t have anything against churches that did; they just decided for themselves. That was their approach. Instead, they decided to give away $27,000. And he admitted, “This is a little scary right now.” But once they did it, he said it was so much fun that they didn’t stay scared. They couldn’t be scared. 

And I’ve heard a lot of words used to describe church budgeting in 2020. Fun is definitely not one of them that I commonly hear. So I asked Andy how they think about generosity at Upward, and he said that it’s not about how much you have, it’s more about how much you trust God. And every time Upward has chosen to open their hands instead of clenching them out of fear, God has shown up in ways that they never could have planned.

Jimmy: 

I love that. And I love that we’re highlighting Upward because my wife, Ashley, and I have some great friends who moved from our church here in Canton to that area. And now they not only attend Upward, but our friend Megan is on their staff. 

Sean:

Oh wow. I didn’t know that.

Jimmy:

So it’s a really cool connection we have personally down there. But from a leadership level, turning down PPP during COVID, I don’t think I’ve heard a lot of churches that turned down free money. And then to think about not only that, but giving away a chunk of money is the kind of decision that sounds crazy in a boardroom, and you just hope that a few years down the road, it makes a great sermon illustration if everything pans out well. But what strikes me from that is they made the generous decision at the least logical time to make it. Anybody can be generous when you have a surplus on your hands, money to burn, but they chose to be generous in one of the most uncertain times in recent history.

I’ll just point back to Andy’s line about trust. He said, “Generosity is less a money issue than a fear issue. And a clenched fist usually means we’re scared, not greedy.” Leaders, we set the temperature here, okay? If the church holds everything tight during uncertain times, we’re discipling people to do the same thing in their homes and in their personal lives. But if we lead with the same kind of faith we wish people would live by, we’re gonna see the faithfulness of God in it. 

Sean, you read a verse from Proverbs chapter three a few minutes ago, and it’s a verse that a lot of us use when we teach about generosity, about our first fruits. I was just challenged recently in reading that chapter that that is wisdom coming from a father to his son about leadership. And so that first fruits thing, that was aimed at the leaders, and they’re saying, “Man, you lead with your first fruits so that other people have an example to follow.” So leaders, we’ve gotta do this. We’ve gotta give people an example to follow, not just to be generous, but to be generous in a faithful sense, even when it doesn’t make sense or when it’s scary. And I totally admire Andy and the leadership at Upward for putting God’s faithfulness front and center that way. It’s an amazing story.

Sean: 

And I wanna share a little more detail about why they chose to do that specifically, because of course, it was an uncertain time for them, but it was an uncertain time for their whole community, right? It wasn’t just Upward. So there’s a few practical things that they’ve done to really build a culture of generosity in their church. The first thing was they created a plan internally to give away 25% of their income. I said that right. 25% of their income. Through their ministry and community partners, they give away a quarter of everything that comes in at their church. And I’ll bet, if you’re a church leader listening to this right now, your reaction is no way. But Andy told me that even though there have been a couple of seasons in their church where they were worried, by the end of the year, they have grown in giving and budget every single year since they’ve done this. In their experience, here’s the key, generosity fuels generosity. The more the church gives, the more people wanna be a part of it. 

The second thing, Upward has a generosity moment, just really practically, for their church in every service. And this is not a, “Here’s what you should give.” It’s, “Here’s what your giving allowed us to do in the community this week.” They are telling stories that are a real driver for generosity. It shows people the purpose behind their giving, and it celebrates what God is doing through the giving of the people in their church. 

The other thing that I think is really fascinating and pretty practical is that they actually budget for this. Every ministry partner that they work with in their community, so just think about these partners in your community, nonprofits, other organizations that are doing great work, that Upward is helping to support financially. They all have their own budget line in the Upward Christian budget. And their outreach director, who they’ve hired to oversee this whole strategy, oversees that budget. And everybody who serves at Upward has the option to go and serve a ministry partner. So it’s not just generosity with their money; it’s generosity with their time. They’ve actually set a five-year goal for volunteer hours with those partners, and that time that they’ve invested with the partners has saved the partners literally hundreds of thousands of dollars at this point. 

So generosity at Upward is about what they’re giving away in terms of their finances. It’s also how they’re empowering the people of their church to go out and be the hands and feet of Jesus.

Jimmy: 

Which is what makes it discipleship. That’s perfect strategy. And man, 25%, that’s like a record scratch for a lot of church leaders listening right now. That’s a lot of money. And I think a lot of leaders are probably thinking, “I would love for us to be able to give away that kind of money,” but keep listening, okay? It is rare to find a church that is that committed to generosity and financially supporting kingdom work outside the church. What I heard was they’re telling stories.

Sean: 

That’s right.

Jimmy: 

Hearts aren’t moved by budget summaries. Nobody read a profit and loss sheet and raised their hand and gave their life to Jesus, right? Stories are the game changer. I heard a statistic, Sean, from Pathways not too long ago. They did some research and some math. They found that it’s gonna take about two Gen Z or Gen Alpha givers to replace the giving power or the giving capacity of one millennial giver. And the stat that got my attention was that same study said it’s gonna take 10 Gen Z or Gen Alpha givers to replace one baby boomer’s giving capacity.

Sean: 

I believe it.

Jimmy: 

The statistic from Bank of America was that Boomers lead in giving to churches and charities; it’s a little over $3,200 a year on average per household. For Gen Z, that number’s about $300 a year. But where there’s hope for strategic movement for church leaders is that same Bank of America research said 60% of Gen Z surveyed said that they were more likely to give to support a cause if they were connected through volunteering or advocacy first. And 48% of the time they got involved through social media discovery, which is stories. If you’re smart, it’s not announcements; it’s stories. So man, that just tells me people, and especially younger people, they don’t give to needs. They give to vision and they give to impact. And if they never hear what their giving did, they’re just gonna assume it didn’t make a difference and eventually they’ll stop giving.

So I love that Upward is telling stories. I think that’s why they have the margin to do what they’re doing. And look at the way they’re blessing so many people through those partnerships. It’s influencing not just how people financially give to their church, but how they’re generous with their time and how they’re blessing their community in all sorts of different ways. It’s beautiful.

Sean: 

That’s right. And they just led the way, right? They were courageous with, “This is what we’re gonna do.” They trusted God. They gave their people a purpose to give to. They gave their people an opportunity to serve. And generosity has fueled generosity, which has just turned into an incredible result in their church. 

Let’s shift into this: a church leader’s listening right now. They would love to be more intentional with generosity being part of discipleship at their church, what do they do? Here’s a couple of areas to start. The first thing is just put generosity on your discipleship pathway. It’s really simple, but I’ve seen it missed so many times. Name it, call it out as a step of faith, not just a line item in your budget or a person’s budget. Give people really clear next steps, whether they’re giving for the very first time or they’re giving over and above sacrificially. It’s the same shift ONE&ALL made with serving that we talked about last week. Move from “we need you” to “you need this.” If the only time that your church hears about giving is when the budget is falling short and you have to have that family meeting, people will hear a need, not a next step, right? 

The second thing is tell people what their giving does. We’ve been talking about this. Upward is telling stories. Do this every single week if you can. That’s what Upward is doing. Their generosity moment answers the question every giver is asking, “Why should I give through my local church?” And if you don’t answer that question, a nonprofit down the street is going to. And that might be okay, but that hurts the church’s opportunity for impact with all of the community partners and with what you’re doing to help grow people spiritually.

One other thing that comes to mind, just be a generous church before you ask people to be generous people. This is exactly what Upward did. And you don’t have to start with giving away 25%. That was their number. Pick a percentage that you feel like you can give away that you can bless others with this year. Build it into your budget and then start growing that every year over time. I think your people will follow what you model more than what you preach. And this is a really effective way, again, proven by what Upward has done, to do that. Jimmy, what would you add to that?

Jimmy: 

Teach people how to manage money, not just how to give it to you. If it’s true that God wants more for people in the area of finance than he wants from them, then we ought to make every giving talk a value add as much or more than it’s an ask. And at the risk of making that sound manipulative, here’s where I think it’ll pay off for churches. And no pun intended in that, but it’ll pay off, and here’s how.

Sean: 

Nicely done.

Jimmy: 

The truth is… You like that? That’s a preacher joke right there. The truth is, Sean, most people in our churches wanna be generous, and I think we all know that. More people would be if they could be. They just can’t because they’re buried under a mountain of debt and they have no plan to get out of it. And you can preach a great sermon on generosity, but somebody who’s three months behind on their mortgage is just gonna walk away feeling guilty. They’re not gonna feel empowered or invited to something. So if we really believe that generosity is a discipleship step, then part of that conversation should be helping people grow in the area of money management so that they can be generous in the way that we believe disciples should be generous. 

Teach them how to budget, help them with a strategy to get out of debt, point them to somebody who can. Offer financial coaching classes. Offer a small group that walks people through a study on personal finance, biblical stewardship. I don’t know what that looks like for each church that’s listening, but do something to connect the practical and the theological dots as often as possible. And what you’ll find is people who get their finances in order usually become your most faithful givers because they finally have room to say yes. And man, if we could just help people not just understand the value of faithful tithing or giving on a biblical level, but we could also help them get into a position to actually do it, now more of our churches would be in a position like Upward to give away even more of our resources to bless kingdom work all over the place.

Sean: 

All right. Before we wrap up, I just wanna remind everybody, Andy’s book is such a great resource. I just looked on Amazon. It’s selling for 10 bucks right now. It’ll be the best $10 book that you’ve bought in a long, long time. It’s called Keep the Change: Transforming Your Community Through Radical Generosity by Andy Craver. 

Jimmy, as we wrap up today, this is an important topic, but I think a tough topic. It’s one that I think all church leaders wanna grow in. What do you think that church leaders need to remember the most from today’s conversation?

Jimmy: 

Remember, generosity starts with trust, and trust is a discipleship issue. If you want generous people, become a generous church first. Tell those stories and help people move toward and ultimately achieve financial freedom so they can give freely. And remember this, your people are watching what your church does and they’re watching you as a leader. So show them what trusting God with finances looks like and give them the tools to follow you in it, and I think they will.

Sean: 

A lot of churches approach generosity as a funding strategy, right? Upward treats it as a discipleship strategy, and then the funding follows that. And when the pandemic hit, the safe move for them would’ve been to just hold on tight. But they opened their hands instead, and they’ve grown every year in giving since then. As Andy said, generosity isn’t about how much you have, it’s about how much you trust God. That is true for the people in your church, and it’s true for your church as well. 

So if you’re not sure your church treats generosity as discipleship, or if you already know it doesn’t, that’s a good place to start this conversation. Our unstuck planning process helps churches assess their discipleship pathway, generosity included in that, where you’re winning, where people might be getting stuck, and what to do about it. So, we help you build a plan to move all of this forward, and if you’d like to learn more about that, you can go to theunstuckroup.com. 

If this series has been helpful so far, would you leave us a review wherever you’re listening right now? It takes you about 30 seconds, but it helps more church leaders find these conversations. Next week, Jimmy and I are back to wrap up the series with a conversation on how reaching people outside of the church is a step in discipleship, and we’re gonna tell the story of a church that’s winning in it. So, make sure you subscribe so you don’t miss it.

Sean Bublitz

Since 2017, Sean has served on the lead team at The Unstuck Group, including roles in consulting, sales, and operations. Previously, he served at Community Christian Church (Naperville, IL) and Granger Community Church (Granger, IN) in weekend service, arts, and senior leadership roles.

0 responses to “Where We’re Winning: Generosity at Upward Christian Fellowship – Episode 475”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Save to list