Most pastors would rather preach on hell than on money. Hell feels less personal.
It can feel self-serving to get up and preach about giving to a church full of people that are paying your salary. And money is a deeply personal thing so there’s that fear that you’ll offend someone. So, many pastors don’t talk about money, and when they do, they do it apologetically.
But Jesus talked about money constantly. And He never apologized for it. He knew that more than almost anything else, our finances compete for our hearts. And when money wins (which it often does), our trust in God as a provider erodes.
Generosity is a vital part of the disicpleship process. If we shortchange it, we’re leaving people undiscipled in one of the areas that is most critical to faith and life. And ultimately, that leads to weaker churches that make little to no gospel impact in their community.
So, how do you make generous disciples at your church? Here’s how one church is doing it.
Generosity at Upward Christian
Andy Craver is the Lead Pastor of Upward Christian Fellowship in Flat Rock, North Carolina. He’s also the author of a new book, Keep the Change: Transforming Your Community Through Radical Generosity.
When the pandemic hit in 2020, they had the same concerns every church had. Andy told me they decided not to take the PPP loan. Instead, they gave away $27,000.
He admitted that was a little scary. But once they did it, he said it was so much fun they couldn’t stay scared. I’ve heard a lot of words used to describe church budgeting in 2020. “Fun” is not usually one of them.
“It’s not about how much you have. It’s about how much you trust God.”
They made the generous decision at the least logical time to make it. Anybody can be generous with a financial surplus, but they chose to be generous in a really uncertain time. And every time Upward chose to open their hands instead of clenching them out of fear, God showed up in ways they never could have planned.
Generosity is less a money issue than a fear issue. A clenched fist usually means we’re scared, not greedy.
As leaders, we’re the ones who set the temperature here. If the church holds everything tight during uncertain seasons, we disciple people to do the same thing in their homes and in their lives. We need to go first in being generous.
1. Make a Plan
There are a few practical things Upward has done to build a culture of generosity.
First, they created a plan to give away 25% of their income. (Yes, seriously.) Through their ministry and community partners, they give away a quarter of everything that comes in.
If you’re a church leader, I’d bet your first reaction is, “No way.” But Andy told me that even though there have been a couple of seasons where they were worried by the end of the year, their giving and budget has actually increased every year.
In their experience, generosity fuels generosity. The more the church gives, the more people want to be part of it.
Look around your community for opportunities to be generous. Maybe it’s other nonprofits, maybe it’s your own ministry work, or maybe it’s just individuals or families who are struggling. Make a plan to be a generous church.
2. Have Opportunities to Give in Every Service
Another strategy Upward uses is having a generosity moment in every service.
Hear me when I say this: This does not mean another announcement. (Chances are, you already have enough of those…)
Upward tells stories of what giving allowed them to do in their community that week.
Hearts are not moved by budget summaries or profit-and-loss sheets. People don’t give to needs. They give to vision and impact. If they never hear what their giving did, they’ll assume it didn’t make a difference.
At Upward, stories has been the real driver. It shows people the purpose behind their giving, and it celebrates what God is doing through it.
3. Budget for it
Lastly, Upward budgets for generosity.
Every ministry partner has its own budget line. Their outreach director oversees it, and everyone who serves at Upward has the option to serve with a ministry partner.
They set a five-year goal for volunteer hours with those partners, and that time has saved their partners hundreds of thousands of dollars. Generosity at Upward isn’t just money. It’s time too.
Pick a percentage you can give away this year, build it into the budget, and grow it every year. Your people will follow what you model more than what you preach.
Go First
Most churches treat generosity as a funding strategy. Upward treats it as a discipleship strategy, and the funding follows.
Generosity starts with trust, and trust is a discipleship issue. If you want generous people, become a generous church. Tell stories. Help people move toward and ultimately achieve financial freedom so they can give freely.
And remember: your people are watching what your church does, and they’re watching you as a leader. Show them what trusting God with finances looks like, and give them the tools to follow you in it. Be a generous church before you ask them to be generous people.



Leave a Reply